Skip to main content
Share this story

Eagles suffer first postseason loss since 2023 as football season comes to an end

Joe Magill | Avon High School | Nov 21, 2026

CLYDE, Ohio—It’s been nearly three years and 13 games since the Avon Eagles last lost a postseason football game, but the streak came to an end Friday in a Division II regional final at Clyde High School.

Avon was unable to get past the size and speed of Toledo Central Catholic, which exploded for 28 points in the third quarter on the way to a 35-9 victory. The Irish, who will face two-time state runner-up Cincinnati Anderson in a state semifinal next week, also posted playoff victories over the Eagles in 2012 and 2022, and each time they went on to win the state title.

For Avon’s senior class, it’s the end of a three-year stretch that saw them win 40 of 44 games and consecutive state titles. Only four starters returned from last year, yet the Eagles played in their 10th consecutive regional final.

“I’m abundantly proud of these seniors,” said coach Mike Elder. “It’s one of the smallest senior classes we’ve had in a while. We’ve been blessed with 36 or 37, but I think this one had 24. They were all committed, 100 percent. What most people don’t know is all the effort that goes into having a chance to even be in these games, and they have invested and poured their heart into it. That’s why it hurts so bad. But I’m really proud of this group. They’ve left a positive legacy.”

The first half was a defensive struggle that saw the Eagles gain a total of 77 yards while Central Catholic countered with 67 yards. Avon held a 3-0 lead at intermission on the strength of a 34-yard field goal by junior Jude Theibert early in the second quarter. The Eagles managed to hold the Irish at bay with two takeaways—a fumble recovery by Josh Kelly, and an interception by Johnny Scott.

A third TCC miscue could have had major implications in the final 2 minutes of the half, but the Irish barely escaped unscathed. On first down from his own 20-yard line, sophomore quarterback Lincoln Sellers was unable to handle a low shotgun snap, and the ball rolled all the way to the goal line. Sellers got to the ball first, and after a scrum he came up with the ball inside the 1-yard line.

“You say you have to be lucky and good,” Elder said. “That quarterback recovers the ball off his hip. If we recover that, we’re up 10-0, right? There were lots of moments in this game that could have made it more competitive at the end, but they didn’t go our way.”

Very few things went Avon’s way in the second half. TCC tailback Jeremiah Fuller, who is being recruited by Mid-American Conference schools, was relatively held in check in the first half with 59 yards on 13 carries. The Eagles opened the half with a punt after gaining one first down, and the Irish came out in a two-back set, a change from the one-back set they used in the first half. The difference was dramatic.

On TCC’s very first play of the half, Fuller broke off a 25-yarder. After a completed pass was called back because of an ineligible man downfield, Fuller burst through a huge hole on the right side and was hit about 5 yards beyond the line of scrimmage. The senior almost went down, but he put his hand to the ground, regained his balance, and sprinted the rest of the way to a 43-yard touchdown that made it 7-3.

“Their back is really good,” Elder said. “That first touchdown it looked like his elbow was down, so that probably shouldn’t have been a touchdown. But that’s a heck of a play. You think about the athletic nature of what he did there, it’s pretty cool. I mean, he’s really, really good.”

Running behind a line that averaged 6-foot-3, and 292 pounds, Fuller romped through the Avon defense for the remainder of the game, gaining 217 yards on 14 carries in the second half. For the game, he totaled 282 yards on 30 carries with scoring runs covering 43, 18, 49 and 1 yards.

Fuller’s ground explosion was in stark contrast to the running game of Avon, which gained just 23 yards on the ground. The Eagles were never able to mount a consistent rushing attack, and when they fell behind they pretty much had to abandon the run altogether. Michael Colburn led Avon with 41 yards on 17 carries and scored the team’s only touchdown on a 5-yard wildcat run on a direct snap from center.

When asked what changed in the second half, Elder said, “They started running the ball effectively. They’re big up front. This isn’t an excuse, but when you let those guys get handsy and grab you, and you’re giving up the poundage that we were giving up, and you have a great back behind that … They ran the ball well and we did not. Any time a team runs the ball better than you, it’s hard to win a football game. They ran effectively tonight and we did not.”

The lack of a running game put extra pressure on quarterback Trevor Sykora, who started the game by completing six of his first eight passes for 53 yards but finished with 12 completions on 36 attempts for 184 yards and four interceptions. One of the interceptions came in the Central Catholic end zone, and another was returned for a touchdown, as Sykora was forced out of the pocket time and again by the stunts and blitzes used by the Irish.

“(Trevor) was under duress the whole time,” Elder said. “We talked about it at halftime, trying to find ways to help him. That’s a tough situation that young man was in when there’s no run game. But there’s no run game because of them. They took the run game away, and you tip your hat to them. But it puts your quarterback in a tough situation. He was running for his life most of the time.”

In the end, the Irish were just too big and fast for the Eagles.

“Their defense is really good,” Elder said. “Really good. They’ve got a great football team with a chance to get this thing done. There’s no question. They’ve got linebackers. They’ve got it at every level. It was tough sledding for us offensively. We just didn’t do enough. Our defense stood in there, but eventually, it looks like they wore us down with their size and power.

“It’s really hard to win a state championship. I’ve always said you’ve got to be lucky and good. It’s a cool moment that everybody should experience, and all these seniors got to experience that. But it’s never been our why in Avon football. Because there’s other schools out there that do it differently, you guys should all know that it will never be our why. Our why is to develop successful young men through the game of football. It’s an extension of the classroom and it’s the greatest lesson you can teach kids.”

Written by
Last update
Joe Magill
Nov 21, 2026
Share this story
ISTE Seal, October 2026–20281EdTech TrustEd Apps Certified for Data Privacy

uReport has been awarded the prestigious ISTE Seal. To earn the ISTE Seal, our product underwent rigorous evaluation by a distinguished panel of experts in education, instruction, and technology. uReport was reviewed and vetted for its alignment with effective teaching and learning practices, including support for research-backed teaching practices, authentic learning, digital citizenship, and responsible use of AI. uReport has also earned 1EdTech TrustEd Apps certification for Data Privacy, providing additional independent validation of our commitment to protecting student data and supporting trusted use in educational environments.

Current Event


Media Gallery

View All