Skip to main content
Share this story

Eagles win penalty shootout, 10-9, to win second consecutive state title

Joe Magill | Avon High School | Nov 17, 2026
PlaceParticipantTotal

COLUMBUS, Ohio—Who says lightning can’t strike twice in the same place?

Not Avon’s boys soccer team.

Okay, so technically it wasn’t the exact same place. Last year the Eagles won the Division II state title at old Crew Stadium on an overtime goal by Brock Harman to take a 1-0 decision. This time around it was the Columbus Crew’s new stadium, also known as Scotts Miracle-Gro Field.

But why nit-pick? Monday’s thriller wasn’t decided until the 23rd penalty kick was taken and missed, sending the Eagles and their supporters into a delirious celebration over their second consecutive state championship with a 1-0 shootout victory over Brecksville-Broadview Heights, the sixth state championship for Avon in less than two calendar years.

“I never imagined winning two state championships,” said senior London Carnie. “There’s no real way to put it. It’s an unreal feeling. I love these guys. We did it last year and we did it again. It’s unreal.”

And it very nearly didn’t happen, but more on that later. This was the fourth meeting between the teams in the past two years, and each time they were even after 80 minutes of regulation play. Last year during the regular season the game ended 2-2, and this year it was 1-1. Last year’s state semifinal was a 1-0 overtime victory for Avon when Connor Britt netted an unexpected wind-blown free kick from near midfield.

The championship match was more of the same. Avon didn’t even have a shot in the first half, let alone a shot on goal. The Eagles eventually had the best chance to score in regulation less than 9 minutes into the second half, but Cole Veverka’s header off a Liam Viers corner kick deflected off the left post.

Avon wasn’t able to possess the ball as it had for most of the season, but the Bees managed only three shots on goal, and none of them really tested keeper Owen Huron. Overall, Brecksville had 18 shots to eight for Avon and eight corner kicks to four for Avon, but the Eagles’ defense was up to the task.

“Coach (Chris Dore) preaches a lot of going to war for each other, and I think that’s a big aspect of what we did,” said Britt of the defensive effort. “We just don’t want to lose. We want to win. So, to not lose, you have to defend, and that’s what we did.”

That’s what both teams did. Brecksville entered the game having outscored its opponents, 16-0, in five postseason matches, and had 11 shutouts on the season. Avon, which finished 18-1-3 with the 18th victory being a school record, entered with 13 shutouts and a 15-1 advantage in tournament play. So, it was no surprise that the teams went through 80 minutes of regulation time followed by two 15-minute overtime periods with very little offense.

“What an opponent,” Dore said of the Bees. “Every time we play Brecksville, it’s a game like that. I mean, it’s a story to tell on its own. Last year in the state semifinals it was the same exact thing. Unbelievable ending. A lot of credit to them, a great team that’s very well coached. I’m just thrilled with my team.”

Brecksville won the coin toss before the shootout and chose to shoot second. Veverka and Carnie were true on the first two PKs, but each was answered by Brecksville. Britt blasted his attempt over the goal in the third round, but then Mateo Muratore and Brayden Carlin kept the pressure on by hitting theirs. The Bees kept answering and had a chance to win the state crown in round five.

Billy Henning lined up to take the shot for Brecksville, and he sent a rocket to the right side of the goal. However, Huron dove to his left and deflected the ball away, saving the season for the Eagles.

“I just committed one way,” he said. “I knew I wanted to go to that side. I got my hands up, got a little lucky, and the rest is history. It was amazing popping up after possibly saving Connor. It just felt really good to be a team player and support my buddy.”

The shootout continued, and Avon never missed a shot. In quick succession, Viers, Daniel Hernandez, Valentino Cruzado, Vincent Palumbo and Liam Gerovac each found the nets, only to be answered each time by Brecksville, although there was a kick in round nine that Huron got his hands on, only to see the ball deflect over him and trickle into the goal.

After 10 rounds, each team had netted nine PKs, which is when things got really strange. Without Dore realizing what was happening, Huron stepped up to take a PK and drilled the ball low and to the right, giving the Eagles a 10-9 advantage.

The assumption was that it was then the turn of Brecksville keeper Alex Daum, but the Brecksville coaching staff stepped onto the field and waived him off. What ensued was a 16-minute delay that included the officials huddling with each other and then huddling with some OHSAA people, apparently trying to decide if goalkeepers are required to participate as shooters in a shootout.

“I’ll be as respectful as I possibly can,” Dore said. “It was just very unorganized. I was talking to the referees about who our next five shooters would be, and I turn around and our goalkeeper’s taking a penalty kick, and nobody knew what was going on. I have a lot of respect for referees. They have a very difficult job. That was just a really bad moment, and I’m glad it ended up the way that it did. If it would have gone the other way, it would have been even more disappointing.”

The final decision was to negate Huron’s PK. When it was first announced, Dore was enraged and let the officials know. After the initial announcement, the officials met again and decided that the shootout would start again with the teams tied at nine.

The Avon bench again exploded in protest, but Dore turned to the bench and said, “Stop. We’re going to go on with this. We’re still going to win.”

When asked afterward what made him so confident his squad would prevail, Dore said, “I wasn’t. It was more motivating than it was anything else. They were sitting there watching me go battle for them. They’re standing around a little while, probably wondering what’s going on. So, after I found out exactly what the circumstances were going to be, it was essentially time for me to go address the guys and make sure that they were mentally focused. It was not a great moment, but it was a very good game. I don’t want that to overshadow the effort put forth by both teams. I think that’s the more important story here.”

Veverka was the first to go for Avon as the shootout continued, and his shot was powered into the nets on the left side to give the Eagles a 10-9 advantage. Thus, the junior had the unusual accomplishment of making two PKs in the same penalty shootout.

“It was the same feeling I had before the first one,” he said. “I’ve got to make this. I’ve got to put my team in a winning position. All year long we practice those, we practice those situations. We just felt really confident going into the second round of pens.”

Next up for the Bees was Walker Boose, who was one of eight players in the match to never leave the field. He had scored on his first PK, but he overhit the second attempt and it sailed over the crossbar, giving the state title to Avon.

“Last year being our first experience, it was so exciting,” Dore said. “This year is no different. I mean, to have that kind of objective on your back from the beginning of the season, where we kind of knew what the expectations were, to have it come to fruition, this is just as valuable an experience as winning your first state championship. This was really a tribute to these guys.

“The reality is I love these guys. I’m super hard on them, but this (state championship) is why. They know that I’ll defend them. I’ll go to bat for them. I’m just so happy. This was special for me, and I thank these guys a lot.”

Written by
Last update
Joe Magill
Nov 17, 2026
Share this story
ISTE Seal, October 2026–20281EdTech TrustEd Apps Certified for Data Privacy

uReport has been awarded the prestigious ISTE Seal. To earn the ISTE Seal, our product underwent rigorous evaluation by a distinguished panel of experts in education, instruction, and technology. uReport was reviewed and vetted for its alignment with effective teaching and learning practices, including support for research-backed teaching practices, authentic learning, digital citizenship, and responsible use of AI. uReport has also earned 1EdTech TrustEd Apps certification for Data Privacy, providing additional independent validation of our commitment to protecting student data and supporting trusted use in educational environments.

Current Event


Media Gallery

View All